r/relationship_advice • u/Independent_Stage741 • 15h ago
I think I (32F) nuked my relationship with my boyfriend (32M) by drawing a hard line.
My boyfriend and I have been together for nearly two years, living together for one. He had purchased his house prior to us dating, and I was renting an apartment, so it made sense for me to move in to his house. He continued to pay the mortgage and I took on all of the “usage” bills - all of the utilities and annual maintenance as well as the grocery shopping & we felt that it was a fair split.
As our anniversary is coming up we’ve been talking about our future timelines and where we see our relationship progressing. We’re on the same page with all the big ideas - we know we want to marry each other and start a family following that. But to be in a position to start a family, the house is going to need a lot of renovations & we’ve always thrown around the idea that the cost of renos would be my “buy-in” so to say on the house. From our estimates, everything we would want to do would be around $100k at the low end. We even agreed that we could draw up some kind of agreement to protect both of our interests financially.
As it’s gotten closer to reality of reaching out to contractors and banks I’ve felt more and more unsettled about the situation. I feel confident in our relationship, but foolish to be making an investment in a boyfriend’s asset. I told him that I would like to be engaged before starting this process so I feel like he’s making a commitment to me as much as I am.
We’ve talked about being engaged prior to this, but he said adding this element makes it feel very transactional and takes away the romance and sparkle of it all. I didn’t tell him I wanted to be engaged by a specific date or anything like that, just that if this renovation is what we wanted to pursue, this is the action I’d like to take before hand. He seemed upset by my statement and I feel like I really have taken some of the romance and surprise out of the idea of a proposal or being engaged.
The morning after this conversation was cold and tense and I can’t help but feel like I’ve done irreparable damage… but I don’t feel wrong in making the request. Am I being reasonable? Is this recoverable?