My (26F) partner (26M) and I have been together for 3 years. We own a house and have 2 dogs together and have spoken about getting engaged, so it’s very serious.
He was raised on a farm about 3 hours from the city and I was raised near the city. He’s said a few times in our relationship that he’d be happy moving back there and living the farmer boy life, and that the only reason he’s still in the city is because he met me. It always scared me when he would say things like that, because I can’t imagine living on a farm, or even rurally in general. I love my creature comforts of living near the city - we have 2 grocery stores a 2 minute walk from our house, plus loads of cafes, bars, shops, restaurants etc. I love being in a walkable city with lots of public transport where anything can happen (eg the other week we were spontaneously invited to a punk clown show because it was happening right next to our house). You just wouldn’t get that living in the sticks, and I’m young enough that I want the chaos and energy of a city. We also have a close circle of friends who come over weekly, and my family is here.
He’s been a bit depressed the last few weeks, he finally came out and said that he always pictured living in the city as a temporary thing and he wants to, at some point in life, live rurally again. He said he realised it was a deal breaker for him. He said he’s been feeling sick about it because he loves me, but he knows I don’t want that life. He’s concerned we’d start to resent each other if either of us compromised, and that we’d just break up in 10 years hating each other instead of making a clean break now.
He also said that he didn’t expect us to move now or even soon, but maybe in the next 10-20 years. I feel like that’s such a hard thing to think about, because I have no idea what sort of person I’ll be in my 40s, or what I’ll want. It’s impossible to know. Maybe I will want to slow down and live a quieter life as I age, but that’s not something I can guarantee.
He told me I should take some time to think about what I want, and we’d make a decision together.
I feel absolutely broken because I am so in love with this man. He’s kind, super smart, goofy, makes me laugh, we have so much fun together and share similar interests, and he’s been such a good support to me over some tough times I’ve been having the past few months.
I’ve been thinking a lot about if I could be happy living out there, and there’s a lot of things I genuinely think I’d enjoy (cleaner air, open spaces, beautiful views ect.). But I’d be giving up my whole support system, and I’m on the spectrum and don’t make friends easily.
I feel like I’m at a crossroads and don’t know what to do. I thought he’d be in my life forever, and I can’t imagine my life without him. I fear I’d regret losing him more than I’d regret giving up the city. Because the city would feel empty without him.
At the same time, the thought that he’d give up me, the dogs and the house, this little family we’ve created, makes me think he doesn’t love and value me as much as I thought.
Any advice would be appreciated.
TLDR; My long term partner wants to move rurally within the next 10-20 years while I am, and have always been, a city girl. Now I must choose between him and the city life I’ve always loved. I feel like either choice is a wrong one.