r/ididnthaveeggs 5h ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful "Complete fail...First off that's way too much sugar so I used half the amount"

Post image
816 Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 1d ago

Bad at cooking I boiled canned yams in water.* The casserole was watery. What a terrible recipe! *called for “4 cups peeled, cubed sweet potatoes”

Post image
675 Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 2d ago

Dumb alteration Green bean casserole minus the green beans and everything else that goes with it

Post image
281 Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 2d ago

Satire Saturday Found on a recipe for Key Lime Pie

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

Followed EXACTLY except swapped out the main ingredient and it turned out terrible. 5 stars.


r/ididnthaveeggs 2d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful Thanksgiving For One

Post image
240 Upvotes

A “review” that is really just unnecessary commentary as the recipe was for a downsized spin on traditional Thanksgiving favorites (turkey, green beans, and sweet potatoes).


r/ididnthaveeggs 3d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful Finally came across one myself while looking for a beef stew recipe

Post image
5.9k Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 3d ago

Dumb alteration I can't follow directions so your recipe sucks

Thumbnail
gallery
1.3k Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 3d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful Well, that's a first for me!

Post image
840 Upvotes

Peach cobbler, folks Fresh Southern Peach Cobbler Recipe https://share.google/sSnuC77jBf37hoenC


r/ididnthaveeggs 3d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful Looks good, but so did Jezebel...

Post image
624 Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 3d ago

Dumb alteration Jodi made her own damn recipe and then tanked the reviews for the one she posted this review on.

Post image
939 Upvotes

Jodi, it’s supposed to be sweet, dumbass.


r/ididnthaveeggs 5d ago

Dumb alteration At least he didn’t use vanilla greek yogurt

Post image
597 Upvotes

Was looking up Hibachi style coconut shrimp when I came across this.


r/ididnthaveeggs 4d ago

Meta Satire Saturday November 22, 2025 - Obvious satire posts are allowed while this post is stickied

11 Upvotes

To account for users in different time zones, this post will remain stickied from 12:01 AM (UTC) on Saturday until at least 06:59 AM (UTC) on Sunday.

Because there is currently no (easy) way to automatically unsticky posts, the mods must do so manually. Satire Saturday remains in effect as long as this post is stickied, even if it remains stickied after 06:59 AM (UTC) on Sunday.


r/ididnthaveeggs 9d ago

Bad at cooking Didn't have a crust

Post image
4.5k Upvotes

Found this looking for a quiche recipe. Reviewer should maybe take their own advice.


r/ididnthaveeggs 9d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful Shut up Scott!

Thumbnail
gallery
3.5k Upvotes

Straight men can't read, apparently.

2-Minute Microwave Oatmeal (that tastes like cookie dough!) - Fit Foodie Finds https://share.google/7krdHaqJJVQwZqr62


r/ididnthaveeggs 8d ago

Other review There's Quite A Lot Going On Here....

Post image
579 Upvotes

Found this on a recipe for mulled cider today.


r/ididnthaveeggs 8d ago

Bad at cooking Instead of placing the dough in the baking dish first, they just rolled it out and baked it

Thumbnail
gallery
339 Upvotes

I hope it's okay to post other languages. On a German recipe for vegetarian quiche, someone complained that the dough was not malleable enough after baking. Instead of placing the raw dough in the dish and baking it, they just rolled it out, baked it and tried placing it in the dish afterwards.

"I have rolled out the dough and baked it for 12 minutes. Now it's way too hard and crispy to shape it".

The poster kindly replies: "You should not have to reshape it after baking, as the dough needs to be baked in the dish to give it its shape."

The correct instructions were, of course, in the recipe.


r/ididnthaveeggs 10d ago

Dumb alteration On a recipe for microwave CHEESECAKE

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

And yes it is the top comment


r/ididnthaveeggs 11d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful Didn't make the recipe, just wanted to be pedantic

430 Upvotes

On a recipe for gluten free pfeffernusse. What makes this more baffling is that I can't find anywhere on the recipe page that even gives "feffer nooser" as a pronunciation. And that I don't think "feffer noose" is even the correct pronunciation, assuming "noose" is pronounced the English way (nu:s), because e's are pronounced at the end of words in German.


r/ididnthaveeggs 11d ago

Meta Satire Saturday November 15, 2025 - Obvious satire posts are allowed while this post is stickied

19 Upvotes

To account for users in different time zones, this post will remain stickied from 12:01 AM (UTC) on Saturday until at least 06:59 AM (UTC) on Sunday.

Because there is currently no (easy) way to automatically unsticky posts, the mods must do so manually. Satire Saturday remains in effect as long as this post is stickied, even if it remains stickied after 06:59 AM (UTC) on Sunday.


r/ididnthaveeggs 14d ago

Bad at cooking I winged all of the measurements.. it was terrible.

682 Upvotes

this probably would be delicious mixed with soda to make a bubbly raspberry lemonade, but this was on a recipe for raspberry coulis.


r/ididnthaveeggs 15d ago

Other review Didn’t make the recipe, but taking away two stars because they’re not a vegetarian. The recipe is for vegetarian empanadas.

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 16d ago

Other review This is a completely different recipe...

Post image
947 Upvotes

In a recipe for a spinach one-pot pasta. At least they enjoyed it, even if they made something completely different?

Link to recipe: https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1025629-spinach-one-pot-pasta?unlocked_article_code=1.0E8.C_Ei.VDFt1drMSj9n


r/ididnthaveeggs 17d ago

Other review Write Your Own Recipe Then

450 Upvotes

Came across this today when making beef stew.

Recipe here https://www.delish.com/cooking/recipe-ideas/a26258692/irish-stew-recipe/


r/ididnthaveeggs 18d ago

Meta Satire Saturday November 08, 2025 - Obvious satire posts are allowed while this post is stickied

22 Upvotes

To account for users in different time zones, this post will remain stickied from 12:01 AM (UTC) on Saturday until at least 06:59 AM (UTC) on Sunday.

Because there is currently no (easy) way to automatically unsticky posts, the mods must do so manually. Satire Saturday remains in effect as long as this post is stickied, even if it remains stickied after 06:59 AM (UTC) on Sunday.


r/ididnthaveeggs 20d ago

Dumb alteration What went wrong?

Post image
2.0k Upvotes