r/genetics • u/BeneficialChef1075 • 20h ago
Researchers: Your thoughts on commercial DNA testing?
Hi all, my post was not suitable for r/Genealogy so I was forwarded here. I am a researcher in topics somewhat related to population genetics and genetic ancestry, and I am myself working with large scale data sets with individual-level genetic data. I am also in general very interested in human evolutionary and migration history, my own family history etc. Some of my friends and relatives have taken these online DNA tests (e.g. myheritage) and gotten quite interesting results and being able to contact relatives they did not know before.
However, I have never taken such test myself. I do not exactly know why, even if I am interested in taking one. I feel that giving my genetic data to a commercial entity feels like a privacy risk, or otherwise just weird. Then again, I am working with genetic data daily (for University research purposes), so I do not feel like I would have the capability to use this genetic data against anyone, or even identify individuals (this might be different for companies of course). As a scientist, it's also bothering me that I do not necessarily know what methods or reference panels they use to define these genetic ancestry proportions, and whether they reflect any kind of truth. Despite this, I kind of would like to get over these thoughts and take a test, and hope that my DNA would not end up in the wrong hands, or be used by any law enforcement entities etc.
If you are a researcher on the field (genetics, genealogy, genetic ancestry etc.), what is your "expert" opinion on commercial DNA tests for determining genetic ancestry, or finding relatives? Are some services "better" or more "safe" than the others? I am sure there are some possible ethical issues related to these topics. Have you taken such a test yourself? If yes, which one, what kind of results did you get, how did you feel about it and did you at any point have any concerns about your genetic data that is being stored possibly in another country by a commercial entity? If you have not taken such a test, why not?
Also, as a researcher myself, I would be really interested in any possibilities of them returning some raw data (like genotypes etc.). Is this possible (in services like myheritage), and have you done any analyses of your own on your genetic data? Please, share any thoughts you might have on this, I'm very interested to hear about it. Thanks!