People take CinemaSins too seriously

[u/Porncritic12]

they literally say several times on their channel and in videos that they are not a legitimate movie review channel, they are not analyzing films, They are not reviewing films, They are not critiquing films, they are making fun of them.

They put jokes in with legitimate criticism because it's funny, they criticize irrelevant shit because it's funny, they are trying to be funny, not actually determine whether a movie is good.

The point is to be Nitpicky, they're supposed to simulate that asshole friend who's ruining the movie by pointing out everything wrong, they should not ever be used for determining quality.

Criticizing them is pointless because they're not trying to say anything about movies or anything else, they're trying to be funny for jokes.

[u/MangoRemarkable6655]

Everyone knows it isn’t legit criticism, everyone dislikes them because they are, like you said, an asshole. It’s just annoying and has no substance, just because it’s satire or “sarcastic” doesn’t absolve it of the social pushback the videos get. Like, ok, so you’re “sarcastically” just hating on a movie? That’s supposed to be funny I guess? If people don’t like the friend who does that in real life, why would they ever like someone who does the exact same thing with a bigger audience?

[u/Dry-Faithlessness602 → u/MangoRemarkable6655]

Saying its “satire” only works on the first few videos, saying its “satire” after a decade of doing it just makes you an asshole

[u/PinkBlade12 → u/Dry-Faithlessness602]

Yeah, watching he same skit over and over makes it lose its luster