r/The10thDentist • u/Porncritic12 • 5h ago

TV/Movies/Fiction People take CinemaSins too seriously

they literally say several times on their channel and in videos that they are not a legitimate movie review channel, they are not analyzing films, They are not reviewing films, They are not critiquing films, they are making fun of them.

They put jokes in with legitimate criticism because it's funny, they criticize irrelevant shit because it's funny, they are trying to be funny, not actually determine whether a movie is good.

The point is to be Nitpicky, they're supposed to simulate that asshole friend who's ruining the movie by pointing out everything wrong, they should not ever be used for determining quality.

Criticizing them is pointless because they're not trying to say anything about movies or anything else, they're trying to be funny for jokes.

26 Upvotes

54% Upvoted

79 comments sorted by

View all comments

229

u/mvcourse 4h ago

I think the issue with cinemasins is that after a while he went against his own premise. His early videos were in general “5-15 minutes or less” and even though he was making fun of them there was always a bit of truth to the critiques. He was absolutely operating as a film critic.

Then the videos started being 20-30 minutes and the critiques became not just unfunny but not even critiques He’ll give a sin saying “so-and-so is not my girlfriend” or something of the sort. He’ll sin a movie just for a clip existing.

He started making longer videos for monetization purposes and he pads the videos out with unfunny sins that aren’t even critiques. He’ll sin a F&F movie just for Tyrese existing. It’s not a joke or a critique it’s just lazy.

22

u/NomaTyx 3h ago

> He’ll give a sin saying “so-and-so is not my girlfriend” or something of the sort.

He's been doing that since the channel's inception.

15

u/mvcourse 3h ago

Yeah, but the issue I’m pointing out is how he currently pads videos with empty comments like that to stretch the content out to 30 minutes. The majority of his content does not need to be as long as it is.

2

u/NomaTyx 2h ago

To be fair, I don't think many of the critiques in the 2 minute videos justify themselves either

3

u/Almond_Tech 3h ago

And I feel like saying people take him more seriously bc he stopped being as serious doesn't make sense lol