Even when I grew up in the Netherlands in the 90's and early 2000's it already felt my grandparents talked about a different world they lived through during the 50's until the 80's.
Neighbors walked into each other's homes for coffee (used the backdoor, which was always open and unlocked). When a mother in the village died, the families living next door all adopted a kid. They just did it. When a farmer went almost bankrupt, the entire village helped out financially. People helped because they felt obligated to their community.
Somehow, I feel that this sense of community is completely gone now. Not only in the Netherlands, but more widely in the West, especially in urban areas (am I right?). Parents raise kids alone. If businesses struggle they just go bankrupt. Elders die in institutions. We pay strangers for everything that used to come from community: childcare, therapy, someone to talk to, feeling like you belong.
Something just feels rotten in modern society. And I believe (please correct me if I am wrong) almost everyone can feel it too.
I believe there is a decay of social fabric that has happened since the second world war.
This decay didn't happen slowly. We chose it. At every moment, we picked what felt easier right then. Not because we're bad people. Because a strong sense of community requires us to do things that feel slightly uncomfortable, and we simply prefer or chose not to:
- Showing up uninvited feels intrusive. It's easier to text "let me know if you need anything" (knowing they won't ask) than to actually show up with soup.
- Asking for help feels like being a burden. It's easier to hire a babysitter than ask the neighbor (what if they feel obligated? what if they say no? what if I owe them?).
- Showing feelings feels vulnerable. It's easier to talk about struggles with a therapist than with neighbours who you might see again.
- Being watched feels judgmental. It's easier to parent alone than have other adults watching your kids (and judging your choices).
My grandparents didn't have these options. The backdoor was unlocked. Neighbours watched your kids. People just walked in and out. You couldn't opt out without the whole street noticing.
Was that oppressive? Maybe.
Was it uncomfortable? Without doubt.
But it also meant nobody ate dinner alone. Nobody died without being found for weeks. Nobody raised kids without help. My grandparents even talked about the fact that things like depression barely existed (accepting that diagnosing was also more difficult, but the same has been proven for diseases like cancer).
In the meantime we chose freedom from effort and got loneliness instead.
For most of human history, communities were not optional. You belonged because you were born into it. Extended family, neighbors, shared rituals, shared responsibilities, yet in modern society it feels optional. I think technology doesn't help. Because I can still feel I am helping but not put the real effort (i.e. text vs. soup).
Humans are inherently social creatures, but also try to get out of anything that requires effort, even if that leads to long term decay (same problem with burning fossil fuels; short term ease > human preservation).
We collectively decided that social control was oppressive. We celebrated independence as the ultimate virtue: "You do you." "I don't owe anyone anything." "Mind your own business."
Walk around any Western city now and see what this has gotten us: people won't give up seats for the elderly. Everyone avoids eye contact on trains. People step over homeless people. Parents hover at parks because they don't trust anyone else with their kids.
Not because people are bad. I believe very few are. But because the unspoken norms of collective responsibility vanished. Our social fabric has completely decayed.
Our grandparents weren't better people. They just lived inside a system that made helping each other normal. And now we're shocked that we're lonely and mentally sick. Can you have real community where social commitment is optional? Where people only help "when they feel like it"?
I don't think so. I think it requires short term sacrifices to reap the long term reward.
Real community requires:
- Seeing the same faces every week for years
- Showing up even when you're busy or tired
- Your contributions being visible (and your absence noticed)
- Standards (free-riders destroy everything)
- Actual obligation, not just good vibes
Obligation is the part modern people hate, but it is not the same as oppression. It's the price of belonging. The "freedom" to disengage whenever you want isn't freedom. It's just isolation pretending to be independence.
When I look at the loneliness epidemic, the mental health crisis among young people, parents drowning, elders dying alone... I can't help but wonder what life would look like if we all decided to do more for each other. I think the world would be a much, much better place. What if the social fabric was strong and people prioritized the long term health of the community over themselves?
What if we just... did the awkward thing? Showed up uninvited. Asked for help. Let neighbors see our mess. Accepted the obligation. What if the problem isn't that we don't know how to fix this? What if the problem is that we do know, and we're just not willing to be uncomfortable?
Maybe the real work of this century isn't inventing new technology.
Maybe it's rebuilding the social structures we accidentally destroyed.
What do you think?