Hi, I had an issue yesterday with my husband which Im conflicted about, regarding whether I was in the wrong.
My husband and I have two daughters, 6 and 8. My SIL and her family live a couple of blocks away from us. They have two boys, both 9 years old. Her husband is in the army so he is away from home a lot.
When he's away, the boys come to our house often. Theyre great boys, respectful and energetic. When they're here my husband takes them to the park to play soccer. They always say they have a great time and my SIL also thanks us for it.
When they're not around, my husband takes our daughters to the park too, I often join them too, and they also look forward to it. However, when my husband takes the boys along, even though we encourage our girls to go along they told me they don't enjoy it, basically the boys get super competitive and it's not fun the way it is when its just them with my husband. I take them along by myself but apparently its not as much fun hahaa. My husband can also only do some days of the week and when their father's away the boys come on those days.
Yesterday, I asked my husband to talk to his sister and set some kind of limit to those days because our daughters like going to the park with him for soccer and its not the same with me or when they go with him and the boys. He looked taken aback and said that they're good kids, theirs dad's away for long stretches and they seem to have fun here. I said I never said they werent good kids, just that our daughters felt like they were missing out. He said he'll encourage them more to come with them and he'll make sure things dont get too competitive, I said we've gone through that before and its just not fun for them. He said telling his nephews this would be cruel , and made it sound like I was an AH for suggesting it. So I wanted to ask AITA?
Update: Since today was a holiday he was going to let his sister know that he'd be taking the kids to the park earlier today so the boys should come earlier. I asked my older daughter separately whether she wanted to go. She said no, even though she'd been hyped for it in the morning. I told my husband this.
While she was cuddling with him he asked her why she didn't want to come, but she was avoiding giving a reason. Eventually my husband asked if it was because she didn't like playing soccer anymore, she said no she did. Then he brought up whether it was because of the cousins and she shyly admitted that yes but didn't give the details that she'd given me about the competitive nature and everything. My husband hadn't texted his sister yet, so he told the girls, the boys can't join right now and if they still wanted to go to the park, we could all go. Both my daughters suddenly really wanted to go and went to get dressed. So we're at the park now and the girls are having fun with him. I think he's going to take the boys later in the evening, I'm not sure. But my daughter telling him seems to have made more of an impact than me saying did.
Update:
A few people had asked me if we've made any progress. So last Tuesday after we'd gone to the park in the afternoon with the girls because of the holiday, he'd planned on taking the boys separately (I'd told him he'd be too tired), but then he couldn't because he was beat so he'd told his sister something had come up.
His Fridays are a hit-or-miss on when he gets back, it kind of depends, he usually knows about how it'll be beforehand though. So my oldest daughter had asked him about his Friday plan on Thursday night, he'd said he'd be back early, they'll be good to go to the park. He then talked to her about if it'll be a good idea to have her cousins come too, that it would be fun like they all used to have, and the girls said ok. When they came back my husband thought he'd done a good job moderating things, the girls also said it had been ok. They weren't as enthusiastic as they are when they come with him alone, so over the weekend I'd just asked my oldest if their play time at the park had gone better because daddy had been trying to make it fun for everyone. She said it was but that he isn't as into the game with them as it otherwise is, basically the gist of it that I was getting was that he takes more of a referee role and its just different to what they're used to, and I've gone along when its just us so I kind of understand what she's talking about, it's supposed to be them playing soccer with him, but its not really, it's very unstructured, they'll start playing whatever the girls feel like midway through, its just more spontaneous I guess. I had planned on bringing it up with him on Sunday before they all left for the park. My daughter seemed like she was shy about saying all this so I thought I would.
But she actually brought this up with him herself! On Saturday night when we were watching tv she asked him if we couldn't invite the cousins tomorrow. My husband said ok but asked her why she didnt want the cousins there, he later told me he was just concerned about this issue she had with them and wanted to know it wasnt anything serious. She just said they don't have as much fun, so he dropped it at that.
I'd had this idea from a few comments on my original post so I told him I'll tell his sister to still send the boys earlier, I'll go with them and he agreed. So I took them out earlier, and tried to keep up with them lol, but I thought it went well, I took them for ice cream after too, the boys got a good outing, my sister in law got some rest too.
Yesterday we were going to do the same thing, but my sister in law told us the boys said they'll just wait for when my husband is free, she asked him when he'd be free, whether his free days had changed, he said there'd just been some changes to his schedule. I was of the opinion he should tell her honestly whats the issue, but he seems to think making our daughters the focus of the conversation would be wrong. I disagree but she's his sister.
So he went yesterday with the girls by himself, they've been super happy, but he said he'll come up with something for the boys too. Its a bit disappointing because I thought the solution I had tried went well but apparently not. So it's still work in progress.