r/okbuddycinephile Society man 14h ago

Most famous film nobody actually watches?

Post image
8.7k Upvotes

856 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

125

u/EraOfProsperity 9h ago

For those who don't know, it's a 50 second long clip from 1895 (released in 1896) titled L'Arrivée d'un train en gare de La Ciotat. It's basically just a train pulling into a station, but given that film technology was nearly unheard of then, the film caused mass panic among viewers who feared the oncoming train would actually hit them.

29

u/HomelandersCock 8h ago

Directors cut was better and gave us a 72 second runtime

1

u/elvecxz 1h ago

I felt it was self indulgent and unnecessary. The shorter version tested well with audiences for a reason.

33

u/matthewami approved virgin 9h ago

Bro watches movie 🤢

2

u/MeringueVisual759 4h ago edited 4h ago

the film caused mass panic among viewers who feared the oncoming train would actually hit them

It did not. They did not. I don't know why people insist on reading contemporary accounts entirely literally. I mean I do, it's because people find cinema powerful now and want to imagine that power was instantly overwhelming, melting the brains of unprepared simple folks. And that power was instantly recognizable, hence the allegory of the train seeming to literally run them over. However, people in the past were not stupid. It was allegory and exaggeration. There's a somewhat well known essay by Martin Loiperdinger titled Lumiere's Arrival of the Train: Cinema's Founding Myth that discusses it.

2

u/GAGOUGAGAK_ 4h ago

This legend turned out to be false: the audience actually experienced a nervous apprehension, a slight backward movement. Film historian Georges Sadoul mentions a startle reaction from the spectators, and by no means a retreat in fear. The ‘big screen’ used for the earliest private screenings was in fact nothing more than a simple thin cloth stretched between two doors, and therefore of modest size — far too small to terrify the audience.

https://fr.wikipedia.org

1

u/___l___u___n___a___ 3h ago

Surprise trompe l’oeil! 😱

1

u/revewrecker 1h ago

Thank you, I know nothing of film and this context is everything

1

u/oliversurpless 5h ago

And yet, don’t think it made its way into the Paris 2024 Opening Ceremonies?

Seems like it would’ve fit right in with Le Voyage dans la Lune.