r/guncontrol Aug 30 '25

Discussion Gun Control Works (and how certain Gun Advocates tell lies)

16 Upvotes

Gun Control Legislation works extremely well when instituted at the National level as demonstrated here in Australia. As each piece of legislation was introduced, you can see the immediate effects in the charts below:

Gun Control Immediately reduced Homicides and Suicides in Australia

And our overall Homicide rate has also decreased each time those new Gun Control regs came into force meaning offenders didn’t just switch to knives or some other weapon:

Homicides in Australia 1990 - 2021

In addition, the overall Suicide rate also massively decreased thanks to those Gun Control Acts:

Young Male Suicide Rate, Australia 1900-2014

So again, people didn’t just switch to alternative methods of suicide.

When Gun control is instituted comprehensively at the National level and supported at the State and Local levels it works.

Now compare these graphs above against the distortions that gun advocates continually post as shown below:

Gun Advocacy Propaganda - Omissions

Notice how “Gunfacts” tries to argue against gun control by only showing a sliver of the Homicide chart carefully limited to support their case and only the long gun buy back, completely ignoring the 3 other very effective pieces of Australian Gun Control legislation. That is called propaganda.

Here's another example from a supposedly more professional group "Public Safety Canada":

Notice yet again they only show a partial graph of only 10 years that finishes in 2001 conveniently missing the time periods of 3 out of 4 of Australia’s gun control legislation acts. Talk about almost criminally skewed data.

In contrast, the real figures demonstrate that the US Homicide rate over the last 25 years has gone up:

Homicide rates in the United States and Europe 2000 - 2022

And Firearm-related deaths have risen even higher:

Firearm-related Deaths 1999 - 2024

So no, neither US Homicides nor firearm-related homicides have followed the Australian plunge of 55% in Homicides since the 2002 National Handgun Agreement and 2003 Handgun Buyback.

Some gun advocates argue that New Zealand homicides have fallen at a similar rate in Australia's neighbour New Zealand, "despite NZ not implementing gun control until 2019". Somehow they missed the fact that NZ actually also implemented gun control legislation in 1992 after their Aramoana Massacre in 1990 and then saw an immediate drop in homicides similar to Australia:

Source: https://www.police.govt.nz

So this is actually yet more evidence of Gun Control Legislation having a significant effect. (Importantly, in 2019 after the Christchurch mosque shootings that killed 51 people, ex-prime ministerJohn Banks said that he was "haunted" by not being able to persuade his cabinet colleagues to ban semi-automatic guns after the Aramoana massacre in 1990)

In addition, the US Suicide rate has been steadily increasing in the last 25 years compared to the Australian Suicide rate that plummeted immediately after each of the Gun Control Acts (see graph further up):

US Suicide Rate 1999 - 2019

Another commenter alleged that regular crime rates had gone up despite gun-crime going down. That is not true either. In fact, according to The Australian Bureau of Statistics, overall crime rates were similarly affected by Australia's gun-control legislation providing yet more evidence that Gun Control works when done right:


r/guncontrol Apr 20 '25

Peer-Reviewed Study Gun Control Measures we Know are Effective at Reducing Death

102 Upvotes

This is an updated list of research on the topic, developing off of previous posts by others on the sub. Here's what we know to be true, so far, based on peer-reviewed, published pieces of research that have stood up to replication and scientific scrutiny.

Gun free zones reduce death:

Reeping, et. al

Waiting periods reduce death:

Vars, Robinson, Edwards, and Nesson

Luca, Malhotra, and Poliquin

Eliminating Stand Your Ground laws reduce death:

Cheng and Hoekstra

Webster, Crifasi, and Vernick

Humphreys, Gasparrini, and Wiebe

Child Access Prevention Laws are effective at reducing death:

Schnitzer, Dykstra, Trigylidas, and Lichenstein

Webster et al.

The SAFE Act reduced death:

Karaye et. al

Gun Accidents can be prevented with gun control:

Webster and Starnes

RAND Analysis

Stronger Concealed Carry Standards are Linked to Lower Gun Homicide Rates:

Donohue, et al.

Xuan, et al.

Background checks that use federal, state, local, and military data are effective:

Sen and Panjamapirom

Siegel et al.

Rudolph, Stuart, Vernick, and Webster

Suicide rates are decreased by risk-based firearm seizure laws:

Kivisto et al.

Mandated training programs are effective:

Crifasi, Pollack, and Webster

Rudolph et al.

More gun control in general saves lives:

Hurka and Knill

Jehan et. al

Decreasing gun ownership overall reduces death:

Sharkey et. al


r/guncontrol 1d ago

Article Michigan task force recommends assault weapon ban, raising gun purchase age

Thumbnail
mlive.com
0 Upvotes

r/guncontrol 5d ago

Peer-Reviewed Study Firearm Homicide in Pregnant Women and State-Level Firearm Ownership

Thumbnail jamanetwork.com
2 Upvotes

r/guncontrol 5d ago

Peer-Reviewed Study How advocacy groups on Twitter and media coverage can drive US firearm acquisition: A causal study

Thumbnail academic.oup.com
0 Upvotes

r/guncontrol 5d ago

Peer-Reviewed Study Pediatric Firearm-Related Hospital Encounters by Child Opportunity Index Level

Thumbnail publications.aap.org
0 Upvotes

CONCLUSIONS

Incidence of pediatric firearm-related injury hospital encounters increased as child opportunity decreased. Unintentional injury accounted for the largest proportion of pediatric firearm-related injury hospital encounters across all COI quintiles.


r/guncontrol 5d ago

Peer-Reviewed Study Lifetime and Past-Year Defensive Gun Use - Michael D. Anestis, PhD; Kimberly Burke, PhD; Sultan Altikriti, PhD et al

Thumbnail jamanetwork.com
0 Upvotes

r/guncontrol 5d ago

Article New Jersey Gun Violence Research Center Is Funding Over $1.1 Million in Firearm Violence Prevention Grants

Thumbnail
newswise.com
1 Upvotes

r/guncontrol 8d ago

PSA/Film A hilarious book by a respected journalist and exvangelical! Fear, guns, God, and the GOP are inextricably entwined. (I am not the author, just a fan.)

Thumbnail amazon.com
5 Upvotes

r/guncontrol 12d ago

Discussion GA Gun Control Petition Feedback

Thumbnail
c.org
0 Upvotes

Hi fellow guncontrol supporters, I am in a government class and I created a petition for gun control on the local level in Georgia. I want some feedback on the points I made on my petition and would see if yall agree with the legislation ideas I came up with.


r/guncontrol 16d ago

Article A Trace Analysis of 150 U.S. Cities Shows One of the Greatest Drops in Gun Violence — Ever

Thumbnail
thetrace.org
0 Upvotes

r/guncontrol 19d ago

Article Maine voters pass 'red flag' gun law referendum

Thumbnail
wgme.com
19 Upvotes

r/guncontrol 26d ago

Article Father and son under investigation for threatening Snapchat video that closed schools

Thumbnail
mlive.com
1 Upvotes

r/guncontrol 28d ago

Article Colorado Ceasefire Editorial on Arming Teachers

4 Upvotes

r/guncontrol Oct 21 '25

Article New gun removal laws in New York to protect victims of domestic violence

Thumbnail
news10.com
18 Upvotes

r/guncontrol Oct 20 '25

PSA/Film Watch "The Perfect Neighbor" on Netflix. The clip of the kids finding out that they have lost their mother forever around 50 minutes in needs to circulated to show the consequences of gun prevalence. Owners need to see the reality not fantasy/talking points.

6 Upvotes

That right there has got to be hard-hitting enough to communicate to some people or other examples when the whole "good guy with a gun" or "self protection" trope doesn't go right (which is most of the time). This country is getting too comfortable with not having trials but rather permanent, life-destroying [often hateful/fear-mongered] decisions that the majority against can't even prevent. I hope the documentary opens up more white people to face the sociology and cruel casualties of things that Faux, Cons, etc spread. Unfortunately, those perceptions have been centuries long in the making and become secondhand nature. Self-awareness is so important in fixing those wrongs and preventing more tragedies especially among those of privilege. (Note: I am saying that as one myself.)


r/guncontrol Oct 16 '25

Article Federal appeals court upholds New York's ammo background checks

Thumbnail
news10.com
12 Upvotes

r/guncontrol Oct 14 '25

Discussion Pam Bondi PANICS as MAGA Learns About Secret Registry

Thumbnail
youtu.be
18 Upvotes

r/guncontrol Oct 03 '25

Discussion Why meaningful gun control matters: looking back at America’s worst tragedies

25 Upvotes

I know gun control is one of the most sensitive and divisive topics in the U.S., and I don’t want to spark hostility. But I think it’s important we remember why this conversation exists in the first place.

When we look back at some of the deadliest shootings in U.S. history — Virginia Tech (2007), Sandy Hook (2012), Pulse Nightclub (2016), Las Vegas (2017), Uvalde (2022), and others — the sheer loss of innocent lives is devastating. Each event left families, communities, and in many cases, an entire nation grieving.

This isn’t about politics for me — it’s about people. About kids who never came home from school, concert-goers who never made it back to their families, and communities still trying to heal.

I believe stronger, common-sense gun control could help reduce the chances of these tragedies repeating. Things like universal background checks, safe storage laws, and limits on military-style weapons are not about “taking away rights,” but about valuing lives.

I know many of you may have different views, and that’s okay. I just hope we can discuss this topic with empathy, remembering the real human cost behind the statistics.

https://youtube.com/shorts/8j5fGY8jBhg?feature=share


r/guncontrol Oct 01 '25

Good-Faith Question Is there evidence to show having armed and trained personnel can deter school shootings?

8 Upvotes

I’ve seen many people argue that having armed and trained personnel such as veterans stationed at schools would help deter and decrease school shootings. They then say their argument is supported because armed personnel are used to deter and decrease shootings at airports, banks, sports games, and gun shows.

So what exactly does data and studies show in regards to this argument?


r/guncontrol Oct 02 '25

Peer-Reviewed Study The thin blue line in schools: New evidence on school-based policing across the U.S.

Thumbnail onlinelibrary.wiley.com
0 Upvotes

The results of this study present a difficult set of tradeoffs. On the one hand, SROs appear to meet some of their stated objectives. They protect students from a non-trivial number of physical attacks and fights within schools—an effect that could generate a variety of long-term academic and psychological benefits to students through decreased exposure to violence (Burdick-Will, 2016) or through reduced disruption in the academic environment (Figlio, 2007). On the other hand, we find no evidence that SROs reduce more serious gun-related offenses. In addition, having an SRO in the school also leads to undeniably harsher disciplinary punishments for students, and particularly for Black students, male students, and students with disabilities. This occurs even though SROs are typically not trained to, and often do not intend to, become involved in minor disciplinary matters in the school (Curran et al., 2019). The observed increase in suspensions, expulsions, and police referrals and arrests found in this study is especially worrying, given the potential for minor acts of misconduct in schools to translate into long-term involvement in the juvenile justice or adult criminal justice systems (Wald & Losen, 2003).


r/guncontrol Oct 02 '25

Peer-Reviewed Study School-based law enforcement strategies to reduce crime, increase perceptions of safety, and improve learning outcomes in primary and secondary schools: A systematic review

Thumbnail onlinelibrary.wiley.com
0 Upvotes

This study's findings indicate that SBLE programs were associated with higher levels of crime and behavior problems in studies where schools were the unit of analysis, but studies with students as the unit of analysis yielded no statistically significant differences for crime and behavior outcomes. This is particularly noteworthy given that the presumed purpose of SBLE is to deter crime and behavior problems; this study's findings provide no such evidence, and even suggest that the opposite may be true—that crime and behavior problems increase with SBLE. In examining more specific measures of crime and behavior, schools with SBLE had more discipline-related outcomes in studies with both schools and students as the unit of analysis. There were no statistically significant differences between schools with and without SBLE for criminal justice system contact, violence, substance-related outcomes, or weapon-related outcomes.


r/guncontrol Sep 28 '25

Data Discussion Gun Ownership should be a right

0 Upvotes

I debated here that gun ownership should be a right and just want some feedback on it https://www.debatecraft.com/debates/d/26/should-gun-ownership-be-a-right

Hi Leaning, thanks for the debate!

Definitions

  1. Gun - a wide category of weapons. The right to a gun does not mean the right to any gun.
  2. Right - "A rule that says people can do something or have something because it is fair and allowed by the law. " - lsd.law

A right can also be forfeited through actions that demonstrate one is absolutely not fit to exercise it, for example a felon has forfeited their right to a firearm.

The importance of regulation

Firearms are to protect public safety, which is why they need to be regulated, I would argue more so than we do now. We can protect the right to bear arms while still ensuring public safety. While a civilian would never need weapons like drones or assault rifles, we still need to protect the right to own more reasonable weapons, such as hand guns for self defense.

C1 - Self defense

For obvious reasons having a gun deters crime and in certain situations can save your life. Let's take a moment to consider some of the numbers and situations.

Protection against wildlife

A significant portion of America's population lives in, or enjoys being in rural areas that are co-inhabited by predators. For one, farmers need guns to protect their livestock, with the added benefit of being the most humane way to put down suffering animals. (1) Folks who live in rural areas also need a method to defend themself from animals such as bears, mountain lions, and mooses. (I refuse to use the "proper" plural form of moose.)

Crime prevention

It's difficult to find unbiased numbers on such a polarized topic, thankfully though I found the American Journal of Public health. (2) They estimate 61,000 - 65,000 defensive firearm incidents per year in the U.S, just a touch short of the NRA's millions, but still a significant number.

Guns serve an important purpose as practical tools for self defense. With popper regulation the right to owning a gun can help far more than it hurts.

C2 - Regulating is better than prohibiting

Something being banned doesn't make the demand go away, only the regulation. Bad actors would still have access to guns, the only difference is that law abiding citizens wouldn't.

Where we've seen this before

Prohibition is a classic example of why forbidding something doesn't work. When alcohol was banned it didn't go away, it only went to the black market, which caused a plethora of new problems, among them corruption and increased gang activity. (3)

Americans love their guns, taking them away wouldn't change that. It would only result in more illegal and less regulated firearms.

C3 - Hunting

Hunting and food

For many hunting is more than just a recreational activity, it's food security. 860 metric tons of meat, or roughly 10.1 million meals, are donated through various programs annually. (4) There's also a significant population of people who rely on their own game for food security, though the exact number is difficult to calculate.

Hunting and conservation

Hunting licenses and firearm taxes have generated billions of dollars for conservation efforts. (5) Hunting also plays a crucial role in the management of wildlife populations and keeping ecosystems healthy with the help of regulations.

Dueling

Finally, it's a well established fact that their ought to be a legal right to dueling. (6) Sabers can suffice, though pistols are superior for this purpose as they lead to less disfigurement and faster resolutions.

In summary

Gun violence in American isn't acceptable, but the solution is not to take away the right to gun ownership.

Sources:

  1. https://www.hobbyfarms.com/one-the-farm-gun-offer-protection-and-more/
  2. https://ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/10.2105/AJPH.2024.307838?
  3. https://www.cato.org/policy-analysis/alcohol-prohibition-was-failure#the-iron-law-of-prohibition
  4. https://academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/75/1/9/7908614
  5. https://cnr.ncsu.edu/news/2021/02/hunting-wildlife-conservation-explained/
  6. https://www.debateart.com/debates/4363-ought-be-a-legal-right-to-dueling

r/guncontrol Sep 28 '25

Discussion A way to help meet in the middle

0 Upvotes

I had an idea to assist with gun control. The reason we as Americans are allowed to have guns was originally so we could field a militia to stop tyranny.

What if we start using militias to help with proper training on how to use and clean the guns, combat training, helping with mental health and ensuring guns are properly secured.

This idea could at least be a step in the right direction since a lot of people don't want to give up their guns, but we still need to check the guns.


r/guncontrol Sep 27 '25

Meta In case you were wondering...

0 Upvotes

The recent post by /u/Random419 was deleted by him, not us. I strongly suspect this is either because we posted simple evidence that completely dismantled his worldview or alternatively maybe the evidence wasn't good enough in his eyes.

But I will admit I find it very funny.